The Modern Cakery Introduce
In the heart of Bergen County, tucked away on the bustling Kinderkamack Road, lies a gem for dessert enthusiasts and event planners alike: The Modern Cakery. For New Jersey residents who view a cake not just as a dessert but as the centerpiece of a life milestone, this Oradell-based boutique bakery has quickly become a premier destination. Founded by Megan and Stephanie—two passionate pastry school graduates who met in this very location years before starting their own venture—The Modern Cakery represents a blend of professional expertise and a personal, hands-on touch. The shop specializes in modern, trend-setting designs that ensure every creation is as visually stunning as it is delicious, catering to a community that values both aesthetic "flawlessness" and authentic flavor.
The atmosphere of The Modern Cakery is a reflection of its name: clean, minimalistic, and undeniably chic. Stepping inside, local visitors are greeted by an inviting storefront that serves as both a pickup point for custom orders and a source of daily treats. For those living in the Oradell, River Edge, and Emerson areas, the bakery has filled a niche for high-end, bespoke confectionery that feels personal. Whether you are planning a grand wedding at one of North Jersey's many estates or looking for an intimate "bento cake" for a child’s birthday, the owners’ commitment to "clean and pristine" finishes ensures that your vision is executed with professional precision. The bakery is more than just a place to buy sweets; it is a creative studio where edible art is crafted daily.
The Modern Cakery is conveniently located at 385 Kinderkamack Rd, Oradell, NJ 07649, USA. This central location makes it highly accessible for residents throughout Northern New Jersey. Kinderkamack Road is one of the county's primary north-south arteries, ensuring that the bakery is easy to reach from neighboring towns like Paramus, Westwood, and New Milford. Its position in a walkable part of Oradell means that locals can easily stop in while running errands or visiting other nearby shops and restaurants. The bakery is also situated within a reasonable distance from major North Jersey venues, making it a strategic choice for event planners who require reliable delivery and setup services for tiered cakes.
For those navigating the neighborhood by car, the shop is easy to spot along the main road. The storefront’s clean, modern aesthetic matches the quality of the products inside, making it a standout feature of the Oradell streetscape. While it operates primarily on a custom-order basis, the bakery maintains regular storefront hours for customers looking to grab a quick treat. The accessibility and visibility of the shop have helped it build a strong local presence, turning passersby into repeat clients who appreciate the convenience of having a world-class cakery right in their own backyard.
The Modern Cakery offers a comprehensive suite of services designed to make every celebration a bit sweeter. They specialize in high-end custom work but also cater to daily cravings through their storefront selection. The services offered include:
- Bespoke Wedding Cake Design: From initial consultation to private cake tastings, Megan and Stephanie work closely with couples to design cakes that reflect their personal style.
- Custom Celebration Cakes: Specialized designs for birthdays, baby showers, graduations, and anniversaries, including complex themes like golf or popular characters.
- Daily Storefront Sweets: A rotating selection of walk-in treats including cupcakes, cookies, cake pops, and cookie bars.
- Specialty Fillings and Flavors: Unique options such as Biscoff buttercream, pink champagne, and fresh strawberry lemonade combinations.
- Event Dessert Tables: Curated selections of smaller treats like macarons and s'mores bars to complement a main cake.
- Dietary Accommodations: Ability to provide gluten-free and nut-free options upon request to ensure all guests can enjoy the celebration.
- Professional Delivery and Setup: Reliable transport for large tiered cakes to venues across the New York and New Jersey region.
What truly sets The Modern Cakery apart are the features that emphasize quality and customer connection. In a competitive market like Bergen County, the bakery’s reputation is built on specific highlights that resonate with local users:
- Woman-Owned and Locally Operated: The business is led by two skilled partners with over 10 years of professional experience in the industry.
- Scratch-Made Philosophy: Every cake and pastry is baked from scratch using fresh, high-quality ingredients, avoiding pre-made mixes or artificial additives.
- Exceptional Communication: Customers frequently praise the owners for being "extremely easy to get in touch with" and providing prompt, professional email and phone replies.
- Clean and Minimalistic Aesthetic: The shop and its products reflect a modern design sensibility, focusing on crisp lines and elegant decorations.
- Short-Notice Flexibility: While they recommend several weeks of lead time, the bakery is known for accommodating last-minute requests when possible.
- Modern Trend Awareness: The team stays updated with the latest baking and design trends, from vintage-style piping to "bento" boxes and modern floral art.
For those interested in starting their own custom order or stopping by for a cupcake, The Modern Cakery can be reached at the following contact points:
Address: 385 Kinderkamack Rd, Oradell, NJ 07649, USA
Phone: (201) 483-6404
Mobile Phone: +1 201-483-6404
When it comes to deciding what is worth choosing at The Modern Cakery, the Biscoff buttercream filling is a clear fan favorite. This unique flavor profile has garnered rave reviews from customers who describe it as "amazing" and a must-try for those looking for something beyond traditional vanilla or chocolate. For celebrations, the Pink Champagne cake paired with strawberry buttercream is a sophisticated choice that is particularly popular for bridal showers and "milestone" birthdays. Its light, fruity notes and elegant presentation make it a consistent best-seller.
If you are visiting the storefront for a quick snack, the chocolate chip cookies are a legendary staple, often cited as the bakery's #1 seller since their first day. Additionally, for smaller celebrations or a thoughtful gift, the "Bento Cake Box" is a fantastic choice—a 5-inch cake that serves about 10 people and can be customized with personalized inscriptions. For the full experience, consider a private cake tasting if you are planning a large event; it allows you to explore their range of moist, butter-based cakes and artisan fillings in a relaxed environment. Whether it's a "flawless" custom masterpiece or a simple, sea-salt-topped cookie, choosing The Modern Cakery ensures you are getting a premium, hand-crafted product that lives up to the high standards of New Jersey’s discerning food lovers.
Would you like me to help you draft an inquiry email to Megan and Stephanie for your next custom cake project at The Modern Cakery?
The Modern Cakery Photos










The Modern Cakery Location
The Modern Cakery
385 Kinderkamack Rd, Oradell, NJ 07649, USA
-
The Modern Cakery
385 Kinderkamack Rd
Sunrise Bagels
297 Kinderkamack Rd
Aroma d’ cafe bakery
246 Kinderkamack Rd
Red Weasel Pastry Shop
270 River Rd
Kinderkamack Hot Bagels
935 Kinderkamack Rd
Glaze Donuts - New Milford
358 River Rd
The Tailored Ham
366 River Rd
New Milford Bagel Express
506 River Rd
Fritzie's Bake Shop
13 Emerson Plaza E
Rispoli Pastry Shop
23 Emerson Plaza E
BorderLine Bagel & Deli
440 Madison Ave.
Goldberg's Original Bagels
185 Kinderkamack Rd
Aleria bakery and cafe 2
160 Henley Ave B
The Modern Cakery Reviews
-
I ordered a custom golf-themed cake for my husband’s 30th birthday and it was absolutely perfect. Not only was it beautifully done and flawless, but it was also sooooo delicious. It was extremely easy getting in touch with the owners and they were able to accept my order even though it was short notice. The bakery is so cute inside and they were both so kind. Needless to say my husband loved his cake and has been talking about it since last week. I got the biscoff buttercream filling because biscoff is his favorite and it was amazing. I think he mentioned he wants to order my birthday cake from there now just to have the same cake all over again! Order from this bakery, you will not regret it! (I added the golf ball candle myself)
Oct 13, 2025 · Simona Nitti -
Megan and Stephanie did an excellent job with our recent custom cake order and we couldn't be happier. I ordered two different 6" cakes for my childrens' birthdays celebrated on the same day and both turned out great. For me, the finishing of the cake from the outside is equally important as the taste. Their finish was clean, pristine and on point. They both tasted amazing as well. We had one chocolate, and the other vanilla flavor. Megan and Stephanie were both easy to communicate with, prompt in replying to emails,and didn't hesitate to answer my questions and accommodate my requests. The ordering process and pickup were smooth. Their store front is clean and minimalistic. Their prices are also fair for the beautiful work they do. Overall, I highly recommend them for your next event!
Sep 25, 2025 · Seta M. Zartarian -
We absolutely love this bakery! All of our cakes, macaroons, cupcakes, and custom cookies come from here, and everything is always phenomenal. The quality is amazing, the treats are fresh and beautifully made, and the service is always friendly and reliable. Highly recommend. Our family orders for every event ! They do a beautiful job!
Oct 16, 2025 · Shazia Majeed -
Funfetti cupcake is so good! I come here once or twice a week, and the cupcakes never fail to disappoint. Good pricing too. The employees are serious and don’t act weird. Coming here again.
Jan 08, 2026 · Gael Marte -
Ordered a customized cake and cupcakes from the modern cakery for my child’s baptism and birthday. From the design to the taste everything was on point. Their customer service is great. Highly recommended
Aug 19, 2025 · annie PD
More Find Bakers
Sunrise Bagels
3.0 (205 reviews)
297 Kinderkamack Rd, Oradell, NJ 07649, USA
Aroma d’ cafe bakery
4.0 (183 reviews)
246 Kinderkamack Rd, Oradell, NJ 07649, USA
Red Weasel Pastry Shop
0.0 (0 reviews)
270 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646, USA
Kinderkamack Hot Bagels
4.0 (153 reviews)
935 Kinderkamack Rd, River Edge, NJ 07661, USA
Glaze Donuts - New Milford
4.0 (777 reviews)
358 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646, USA
The Tailored Ham
5.0 (28 reviews)
366 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646, USA
New Milford Bagel Express
4.0 (108 reviews)
506 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646, USA
Fritzie's Bake Shop
4.0 (40 reviews)
13 Emerson Plaza E, Emerson, NJ 07630, USA
Rispoli Pastry Shop
4.0 (393 reviews)
23 Emerson Plaza E, Emerson, NJ 07630, USA
BorderLine Bagel & Deli
3.0 (194 reviews)
440 Madison Ave., New Milford, NJ 07646, USA
Goldberg's Original Bagels
4.0 (178 reviews)
185 Kinderkamack Rd, Emerson, NJ 07630, USA
Aleria bakery and cafe 2
4.0 (35 reviews)
160 Henley Ave B, New Milford, NJ 07646, USA
Categories
Popular
Butterly Bakeshop4.0 (102 reviews)
Bebe Bakes4.0 (49 reviews)
Zaro's Family Bakery3.0 (4 reviews)
Vermont Bread Co4.0 (4 reviews)
Santos Bakery4.0 (152 reviews)
Pick A Bagel3.0 (1052 reviews)Trending Blog Posts
Top Bakeries in Nashville for Fresh Biscuits and Bread
Top Bakeries in Houston for Fresh Bread and Affordable Pastries
Best Bakeries in Portland for Fresh Sourdough and Natural Fermentation
Best Bakeries in Denver for Fresh Bread and Local Ingredients
Best Bagels in New York from Local Bakeries
Best Bakeries in Dallas for Handmade Bread and Pastries
