Bagel Girl Introduce
In the bustling landscape of Westchester County, finding an authentic spot for breakfast and baked goods is a priority for many New Yorkers. Bagel Girl, located in White Plains, has established itself as a go-to destination for locals who appreciate the quintessential New York bagel experience. For those of us living in or commuting through the New York region, a bakery is more than just a place to buy bread; it is a community hub where the day begins with the smell of toasted seeds and fresh dough. Bagel Girl captures this local spirit by offering a menu that focuses on freshness, speed, and the classic flavors that define our regional palate.
The establishment operates with a commitment to transparency and quality, features that have made it a "hidden gem" for both residents and those passing through on road trips. As a professional bakery and breakfast joint, Bagel Girl emphasizes the "made-to-order" philosophy. This means that your meal isn't sitting under a heat lamp; it is prepared right in front of you using fresh ingredients. For a New Yorker on the move, this balance of artisanal quality and "grab and go" efficiency is exactly what is needed to navigate a busy morning schedule. Whether you are looking for a pillowy bagel or a hearty roll, the craftsmanship behind their baking process is evident in every bite.
Location and Accessibility
Conveniently situated at 731 NY-22, White Plains, NY 10603, Bagel Girl is perfectly positioned for easy access. Route 22 is a major artery in Westchester, making this bakery an ideal pit stop for commuters heading toward the city or locals running errands in the White Plains and North Castle areas. Its location is particularly favorable for those who prefer a quick, reliable stop without the hassle of navigating deep into a crowded downtown district. The storefront is visible and accessible, catering to the fast-paced lifestyle of the New York metropolitan area.
While the interior layout is cozy and efficient, it is primarily designed for the high-volume "grab and go" style that New Yorkers demand. There is a limited amount of seating available for those who wish to enjoy their meal on-site, but the business model excels at getting high-quality food into the hands of customers quickly. For those traveling through the state or local residents looking for a dependable breakfast before work, the accessibility of the NY-22 location ensures that you can get in, get your fresh bagel, and get back on the road with minimal delay.
Services Offered
Bagel Girl offers a variety of services tailored to the needs of the modern diner. Their service model focuses on flexibility and freshness, ensuring that every customer receives a meal tailored to their specific preferences. The primary services include:
UL
LI Made-to-Order Sandwiches: Every breakfast and lunch sandwich is prepared fresh in front of the customer, allowing for full customization of ingredients and toppings.
LI Online Ordering and Takeout: The bakery utilizes platforms like Uber Eats to facilitate easy ordering for those who want to pick up their food or have it delivered directly to their home or office.
LI Grab and Go Service: Designed for speed, the service counter is optimized to handle morning rushes efficiently, providing a seamless experience for commuters.
LI Daily Fresh Baking: A wide selection of bagels and rolls are baked daily to ensure the perfect texture—crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside.
LI Custom Omelette Preparation: Beyond bready treats, the kitchen prepares multi-egg omelettes made with fresh ingredients to order.
Features / Highlights
What distinguishes Bagel Girl from other local eateries are the specific details of their food preparation and the atmosphere created by the staff. Based on local feedback and operational standards, the highlights include:
UL
LI Fresh Ingredients: A steadfast commitment to using high-quality, fresh ingredients that are visible to the customer during the preparation process.
LI Friendly Professional Staff: The team is noted for their welcoming demeanor, providing a positive start to the day for local patrons.
LI Authentic Textures: Their bagels are praised for achieving the traditional New York standard—a distinct, crunchy exterior paired with a pillowy, soft interior.
LI Versatile Bread Options: While bagels are the star, the bakery also offers high-quality rolls and toast options to suit different sandwich preferences.
LI Extensive Menu Variety: A diverse range of menu options that cater to different breakfast cravings, from simple buttered bagels to complex protein-packed sandwiches.
Contact Information
For those looking to place an order or inquire about daily specials, Bagel Girl can be reached through the following channels:
Address: 731 NY-22, White Plains, NY 10603, USA
Phone: (914) 689-3145
Mobile Phone: +1 914-689-3145
What is worth choosing
If you are visiting Bagel Girl for the first time, the "toasted bagel" is an essential choice. It perfectly represents the bakery’s ability to master the classic New York staple, providing that sought-after contrast between a crispy crust and a light, airy center. However, many local regulars and travelers highly recommend opting for a sandwich on one of their fresh rolls. The rolls are frequently cited as being exceptionally good, offering a soft but sturdy vessel for egg, cheese, and meat combinations.
For those seeking a more substantial meal, the omelettes are a popular choice. When ordering, especially through third-party apps, it is a good idea to confirm the inclusions of your meal. While the omelettes are made with a generous four-egg base and fresh fillings, checking the current menu descriptions ensures you know exactly which sides—like toast or home fries—are included in the current pricing. This attention to detail ensures a satisfying experience. Ultimately, whether you are grabbing a quick coffee and a buttered bagel or a fully loaded breakfast sandwich, Bagel Girl provides the authentic, fresh, and friendly service that New Yorkers expect from their local neighborhood bakery. It is a reliable Westchester staple that proves why fresh, made-to-order food always wins over pre-packaged alternatives.
Would you like me to help you draft a specific catering inquiry or a social media post to promote your next visit to Bagel Girl?
Bagel Girl Photos










Bagel Girl Location
Bagel Girl
731 NY-22, White Plains, NY 10603, USA
-
Bagel Girl
731 NY-22
Just Chippy's
931 N Broadway
Amy’s Custom Cupcakes ( NOT A STORE FRONT)
25 Rockledge Ave
Crema e Crosta
25 Lakeview Ave
Coco Choco Bakery
1 Harding Ave
Auntie Anne's
19 Mamaroneck Ave Space K-2A
Little Bit O' Love Bakery
6 White Deer Ln
Auntie Anne's
100 Main St
Auntie Anne's
125 Westchester Ave #925
Heaven's Kiss
75 S Broadway 4th fl
Tous les Jours Bakery Cafe
125 Mamaroneck Ave
Duck Donuts
393 Tarrytown Rd Suite 393
Bagel Oven Inc
401 Tarrytown Rd
Bagel Girl Reviews
-
Great breakfast joint and great food -Made to order in front of you -Great menu options for a grab and go style place -Friendly staff -Delicious food Popped in on a roadtrip back to ohio and stumbled across this gem. Foods so good and made in front of you with fresh ingredients. Toasted bagel was crunchy on the outside and pillowy on the inside, so good. Highly recommend getting your sandwich on a roll though, again, so good. Not a ton of seating but not needed in our case
Jun 26, 2025 · Devin Sierra -
Today, I ordered an omelette online for takeout. In the menu photo, the omelette was shown with toast and home fries. Unfortunately, my order did not include either of those items. If toast and home fries are not included, there should be a clear explanation, or the menu photos should be updated accordingly. Paying $18 for just a four-egg omelette without any sides was disappointing. Please update your Uber Eats menu to accurately reflect what is included. Once this issue is addressed, I will be happy to update my rating.
Jan 07, 2026 · Mihai İhsan -
I often stop at this place for a bagel when driving to work in the morning. They have a decent variety of bagels along with many cream cheese choices. The bagels are delicious. However, they do not feel or taste as soft compared to other places. Overall, it's a nice place. Thank You.
Nov 05, 2025 · Vincent C. -
Nice and clean place. Prices do match white plains so i’m not sure why someone complained in another review. 🤦🏻♂️ Food was good. Only issue i had was 1)no customer bathroom 2) they close at 2PM but shut the grill at 1PM. I came at 1:15 and was limited to what i can order. I recommend maybe shutting the grill 10-15 mins prior to closing to service clients? Just a thought.
Jun 08, 2023 · T T -
I wanted to try a new place for breakfast and this was not it for me. it’s ok at best and the food It’s not anything that was worth my money. I ordered a BLT on a bagel. My bagel was burned. The bacon was burned and they charge me $14.95. I don’t think that a BLT is worth that amount of money. I will also add that I got a small cup of coffee so my bill was $15 for two items.
Nov 21, 2025 · k&A's world
More Find Bakers
Just Chippy's
4.0 (188 reviews)
931 N Broadway, White Plains, NY 10603, USA
Amy’s Custom Cupcakes ( NOT A STORE FRONT)
5.0 (42 reviews)
25 Rockledge Ave, White Plains, NY 10601, USA
Crema e Crosta
5.0 (3 reviews)
25 Lakeview Ave, West Harrison, NY 10604, USA
Coco Choco Bakery
3.0 (689 reviews)
1 Harding Ave, White Plains, NY 10606, USA
Auntie Anne's
3.0 (18 reviews)
19 Mamaroneck Ave Space K-2A, White Plains, NY 10601, USA
Little Bit O' Love Bakery
5.0 (24 reviews)
6 White Deer Ln, West Harrison, NY 10604, USA
Auntie Anne's
4.0 (6 reviews)
100 Main St, White Plains, NY 10601, USA
Auntie Anne's
4.0 (19 reviews)
125 Westchester Ave #925, White Plains, NY 10601, USA
Heaven's Kiss
5.0 (1 reviews)
75 S Broadway 4th fl, White Plains, NY 10601, USA
Tous les Jours Bakery Cafe
4.0 (144 reviews)
125 Mamaroneck Ave, White Plains, NY 10601, USA
Duck Donuts
4.0 (176 reviews)
393 Tarrytown Rd Suite 393, White Plains, NY 10607, USA
Bagel Oven Inc
3.0 (140 reviews)
401 Tarrytown Rd, White Plains, NY 10607, USA
Categories
Popular
Les Gateaux de Marie4.0 (348 reviews)
Betel Party Supply4.0 (522 reviews)
D'Lili Bakery3.0 (126 reviews)
Black Cat Bakery4.0 (3 reviews)
Just Chippy's4.0 (188 reviews)
Los Girasoles Bakery de La Doña, Inc.4.0 (143 reviews)Trending Blog Posts
Top Bakeries in Nashville for Fresh Biscuits and Bread
Top Bakeries in Houston for Fresh Bread and Affordable Pastries
Best Bakeries in Denver for Fresh Bread and Local Ingredients
Best Bakeries in Houston for Daily Bread and Artisan Desserts
Best Bagels in New York from Local Bakeries
Best Bakeries in Dallas for Handmade Bread and Pastries
