There Should Always Be Cake

In the vibrant heart of the Bronx, where community celebrations and family milestones are a way of life, one boutique bakeshop has redefined the standard for edible art. There Should Always Be Cake, located on the bustling East Tremont Avenue, operates on a simple yet profound philosophy: that no occasion is too small for a masterpiece. For New Yorkers navigating the diverse culinary landscape of the 10461 zip code, this bakery has become a destination for those who refuse to compromise on either aesthetics or flavor. From whimsical birthday designs to elegant tiered wedding cakes, the shop serves as a creative studio where sugar, flour, and imagination intersect.

The name itself serves as a daily reminder of the shop’s mission to bring joy to the neighborhood. In a fast-paced city like New York, finding a local baker who treats every order with "true artistry" is a rare luxury. There Should Always Be Cake has built its reputation not just on its visual output, but on the consistency of its textures and the depth of its flavors. It is a place where residents from Pelham Bay to Westchester Square come when they need a centerpiece that will have every guest at the party asking, "Where did you get this cake?" With a team of "gem-like" staff members known for their friendly demeanor and accommodating service, the bakery has successfully cultivated a loyal following that spans years of celebrations.

Location and Accessibility

There Should Always Be Cake is conveniently situated at 2465 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10461, USA. This prime location sits on one of the borough’s most iconic thoroughfares, making it a central point for those living in or traveling through the East Bronx. The shop’s presence on East Tremont Avenue places it within a lively commercial district, surrounded by local shops and eateries, which makes it an easy addition to a day of neighborhood errands.

For those utilizing New York City’s public transportation system, the bakery is highly accessible. It is located near several major bus routes, including the Bx40 and Bx42, which run directly along East Tremont Avenue. Additionally, the Zerega Av and Westchester Sq - East Tremont Av subway stations (6 train) are within a reasonable distance, providing a direct link for customers traveling from Manhattan or other parts of the Bronx. While street parking in this busy section of the Bronx can sometimes be a challenge during peak hours, many local patrons find that the shop’s curbside delivery and efficient pickup options make the process seamless. For those coming from further afield, the bakery’s proximity to the Hutchinson River Parkway and the Cross Bronx Expressway ensures a relatively straightforward commute by car.

Services Offered

• Customized specialty cake design for weddings, birthdays, baby showers, and religious milestones.
• Expert production of "Drip Rose" cakes and "Unicorn" cakes, which have become signature favorites for local celebrations.
• A diverse retail selection of gourmet cupcakes featuring a unique "ice-cream scoop" style of frosting.
• Organic and vegan-friendly baking options, including highly-praised vegan chocolate cupcakes and chocolate chip cookies.
• Curbside delivery and on-site assembly for delicate or multi-tiered event cakes to ensure perfect presentation.
• Long-distance delivery services (subject to availability) for clients outside the immediate Bronx area.
• Short-notice order fulfillment for celebration cakes, accommodating the busy and often unpredictable schedules of New Yorkers.

Features / Highlights

• A commitment to "true artistry," where each cake is treated as a unique work of art tailored to the client’s specific vision.
• Professional and accommodating service from a team that local customers frequently describe as "gems" and "very friendly."
• Consistent high-quality results, with long-term customers returning for years due to the reliability of the taste and texture.
• Inclusive menu options that cater to the growing demand for high-quality, plant-based, and organic treats in the Bronx.
• Extended store hours from Tuesday through Saturday (9am - 7pm), providing ample opportunity for after-work pickups.
• A reputation for being "very accommodating" even on short notice, a vital feature for the fast-moving New York event scene.

Contact Information

To start the process of designing your next custom cake or to check on the daily availability of their famous cupcakes, you can reach the bakeshop through their primary contact channels. Given the artisanal nature of their work, phone consultations are typically available Tuesday through Saturday to discuss the finer details of your event.

Address: 2465 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10461, USA

Phone: (855) 353-2253

What is worth choosing

When ordering from There Should Always Be Cake, the first-time visitor or the seasoned regular alike should look toward their signature "Drip Rose" cakes. These cakes have become a staple for birthdays in the Bronx, praised for their elegant aesthetics and the perfect balance of moist cake and rich frosting. For children’s parties, the "Unicorn" cake is a standout choice that never fails to impress; as one regular customer noted, guests "absolutely loved them and ate every single bit." The artistry in these designs is matched only by the "great texture and flavors" that have become the bakery's hallmark.

For those with dietary restrictions or a preference for organic ingredients, the vegan selection is surprisingly robust for a neighborhood bakeshop. The vegan chocolate chip cookies are frequently cited as "one of the best," offering a perfect balance of flavor that isn't overly sweet. If you are just stopping by for a snack, the vanilla cupcakes with their generous, scoop-sized frosting are a must-try. However, the true value of this bakery lies in its ability to work "individually with each customer." If you have a specific, detailed vision for a celebration, we recommend choosing a custom consultation. The ladies who work here are experts at translating a theme—whether it's a favorite character, a color palette, or a sophisticated floral arrangement—into a delicious reality. Ultimately, whether it is a small box of cupcakes for a quiet evening or a massive tiered cake for a gala, choosing There Should Always Be Cake ensures that your event will be remembered as much for the dessert as for the occasion itself.

The presence of such a high-caliber bakeshop on East Tremont Avenue is a testament to the thriving local business culture of the Bronx. It provides a level of craftsmanship and customer care that rivals any boutique bakery in the city, all while remaining firmly rooted in the community it serves. For those in the New York region looking for a bakery that treats every order like a masterpiece, There Should Always Be Cake is a destination that consistently delivers on its name.

There Should Always Be Cake

2465 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10461, USA