Bagel & More

In the heart of Hartsdale, New York, Bagel & More stands as a quintessential neighborhood anchor for the local community and Westchester commuters alike. For over 18 years, this establishment has weathered the highs and lows of the region—including a significant restoration following Hurricane Ida—to emerge as a resilient and beloved "regular spot." For those who have recently moved from bagel hubs like Queens or Brooklyn, Bagel & More often serves as the "find" that finally satisfies that specific New York craving for high-quality dough at an affordable price. It is a place where the morning rush is a familiar rhythm and the scent of fresh-baked bagels provides a comforting start to the day for the Scarsdale and Hartsdale residential corridors.

The shop operates with a philosophy of abundance, captured perfectly by its name. While the bagel is the foundation, the "More" refers to an expansive menu that functions almost like a classic New York deli-diner hybrid. From hot breakfast platters and omelets to crispy fried chicken and fruit bowls, the establishment aims to be a one-stop shop for any appetite. The atmosphere is friendly and community-oriented, often serving as a local gathering point on weekend mornings. Whether you are popping in for a quick "grab and go" before catching the Metro-North or settling into one of their indoor stools for a leisurely brunch, Bagel & More offers a slice of authentic Westchester life characterized by its bustling energy and diverse food options.

Location and Accessibility

Bagel & More is strategically located at 224 E Hartsdale Ave, Hartsdale, NY 10530, USA. Its position on East Hartsdale Avenue places it in the center of one of Westchester's most walkable and vibrant commercial strips. The bakery is situated just a short stroll from the Hartsdale Metro-North station, making it an incredibly convenient destination for city-bound commuters who need a reliable breakfast or a fresh bag of bagels for the office. The surrounding area is a blend of residential charm and active commerce, ensuring the shop is always within reach for those living in the local apartments and nearby Scarsdale homes.

Accessibility is a key advantage of this location. For those driving, the shop is easily reached from major arteries like the Sprain Brook Parkway and Central Park Avenue. While street parking on East Hartsdale Avenue is the primary option, the high turnover of the shop means spaces often become available for quick pickups. For those who prefer the convenience of modern service, Bagel & More is well-integrated with digital platforms, offering robust delivery and pickup services through partners like DoorDash, Seamless, and Uber Eats. The shop also features a small outdoor seating area during the warmer months, providing a perfect spot to enjoy the village atmosphere while you eat.

Services Offered

• On-site baking of traditional New York-style bagels in a wide variety of classic flavors.
• Full-service breakfast grill featuring made-to-order egg sandwiches, omelets, and pancakes.
• Diverse lunch menu including deli sandwiches, burgers, wraps, and specialty heroes.
• Family-sized bagel packs and affordable cream cheese sets for large gatherings or home stock.
• A wide array of beverages ranging from hot coffee and tea to bubble tea and milkshakes.
• Freshly prepared side salads (macaroni, potato, coleslaw) and hearty fruit bowls.
• Specialty platters including smoked fish (Nova, Sable, White Fish) served with traditional fixings.
• Catering services for local events, corporate meetings, and family celebrations.

Features / Highlights

• Neighborhood Value: Known as a "gem" for its ability to provide high-quality food at prices that are often more affordable than competitors in the Scarsdale area.
• Extensive Variety: The menu lives up to the name "And More," offering everything from Mexican-inspired chorizo wraps to classic American cheeseburgers and fried chicken.
• Scratch-Made Quality: The establishment takes pride in making their own bagels and deli salads from scratch, ensuring a level of freshness that defines the local brand.
• Community Resilience: Having successfully reopened after major flood damage, the shop is a symbol of local perseverance and is deeply supported by its loyal customer base.
• In-House Breakfast Expertise: The breakfast sandwiches are a community staple, often praised for their fresh ingredients and "fantastic" execution on any choice of carb.
• Family Pack Specials: The bakery offers "Family Packs" (often including 10 to 13 bagels) that are a go-to resource for weekend family breakfasts and brunches.
• Vibrant Atmosphere: Features indoor stools and tables as well as seasonal outdoor seating, creating an inviting environment for a quick bite or a relaxed meal.

Contact Information

Address: 224 E Hartsdale Ave, Hartsdale, NY 10530, USA

Phone: (914) 722-4444

Mobile Phone: +1 914-722-4444

What is worth choosing

When you visit Bagel & More, the clear priority for most regulars is the fresh-baked bagel selection. For those seeking the classic experience, an "Everything" or "Sesame" bagel with their house-made scallion or vegetable cream cheese is a top-tier choice. However, the shop is also famous for its "Family Pack," which is arguably the most cost-effective way to sample the bakery's variety; these packs are highly worth choosing for weekend visitors who want to stock up for the week. For a heartier start, the "Hungryman Hero" or the Western Omelette platter provides a robust meal that locals frequently describe as "fantastic."

If you are in the mood for something beyond the standard bagel, the specialty wraps and signature sandwiches are excellent alternatives. The "B&M Wrap" (often featuring egg whites and spinach) and the "Philly Cheese Steak" are standout lunch options. For those with a sweet tooth, don't overlook their beverage and snack menu—their milkshakes and bubble tea offer a delightful treat that you wouldn't typically expect from a traditional bagel shop. While the shop is occasionally busy, leading to some variability in custom orders during peak rushes, sticking to their "best sellers" like the Nova Salmon platter or a simple Bacon, Egg, and Cheese ensures a satisfying and authentically "New York" experience. No matter what you choose, the combination of freshness, variety, and community spirit makes every visit to this Hartsdale staple a worthwhile stop.

Ultimately, Bagel & More is a testament to the fact that the best food spots are often those that become part of the local fabric. By offering "great prices" and a menu that refuses to be limited, they have created a reliable haven for food lovers in the 10530 area. Whether you are a newcomer to Westchester or a lifelong resident, this shop invites you to explore the "and more" side of the bagel world, proving that tradition and variety can go hand-in-hand. It remains a must-visit destination for anyone who values a true neighborhood gem with a resilient heart and a very full menu.

Bagel & More

224 E Hartsdale Ave, Hartsdale, NY 10530, USA