Butterworths Bagel Bakery

In the heart of the Northern Valley, specifically within the community-centric borough of Old Tappan, New Jersey, Butterworths Bagel Bakery has established itself as an indispensable local institution. For those of us living in Bergen County, a "good bagel" is not just a preference—it is a standard by which we measure our morning routine. Butterworths has consistently met and exceeded this standard, earning a reputation for artisanal excellence and a welcoming, small-town atmosphere. This family-owned gem provides the quintessential New Jersey bagel experience, where the commitment to traditional baking methods results in a product that is perfectly crusty on the outside and wonderfully chewy on the inside.

The bakery serves as a bustling hub for the local community, often seeing a steady stream of regulars who appreciate the "well-oiled machine" efficiency of the staff. Whether it is a quiet Tuesday morning or a lively weekend where the line occasionally stretches out the door, the team at Butterworths manages the rush with professional grace. For New Jersey residents, finding a reliable spot that balances high-speed service with the warmth of a local mom-and-pop shop is a rare find, and it is exactly what has kept Butterworths at the top of local "best of" lists for years. The bakery isn't just a place to buy bread; it is a landmark where the aroma of fresh dough and the sound of neighborly chatter define the start of the day.

Location and Accessibility

Butterworths Bagel Bakery is conveniently located at 50 Bi State Plaza, Old Tappan, NJ 07675. Situated within the popular Bi State Plaza shopping center, the bakery benefits from a prime location that serves not only Old Tappan but also neighboring towns like River Vale, Harrington Park, and Northvale. Its position in a central shopping plaza makes it an easy "one-stop" destination for locals who are running errands, heading to work, or dropping children off at nearby schools. The plaza offers ample parking, which is a significant convenience for the morning rush when speed and ease of access are paramount for busy commuters.

The shop is easily accessible from major local thoroughfares, including Old Tappan Road and Central Avenue. For those of us navigating the suburban landscape of Northern Bergen County, the bakery's location provides a stress-free transition from the road to the counter. The storefront itself is clean, bright, and organized, designed to handle high-volume traffic while maintaining an inviting feel. Whether you are a lifelong resident or someone just passing through the scenic Northern Valley, the bakery's presence in Bi State Plaza makes it a reliable and easy-to-find landmark for high-quality breakfast and lunch options.

Services Offered

Butterworths Bagel Bakery offers a comprehensive suite of services that cater to individual cravings as well as large group needs. Their operations are designed to provide fresh food quickly, ensuring that quality is never sacrificed for speed. The following services are core to the Butterworths experience:

UL

LI Hand-Rolled Bagel Production: Fresh bagels are baked daily on the premises, featuring a wide array of classic and specialty flavors including everything, sesame, pumpernickel, and jalapeño cheddar.

LI Made-to-Order Breakfast Wraps: A fan-favorite service where customers can customize their morning wraps with various proteins, cheeses, and fresh vegetables.

LI Full Deli Sandwich Menu: Beyond breakfast, the bakery serves overstuffed deli sandwiches using premium Boar's Head meats and fresh-baked rolls or bagels.

LI Bakery and Pastry Case: A well-stocked selection of muffins, Danishes, crumb cakes, and seasonal pastries that are updated throughout the year.

LI Catering Solutions: Offering assorted bagel platters, pastry trays, and sandwich spreads for local office meetings, family gatherings, and community events.

LI Bulk Orders: Providing "Baker's Dozen" specials and value packs that include their freshly made signature cream cheeses.

Features / Highlights

What truly distinguishes Butterworths Bagel Bakery from other competitors in the New Jersey region is a combination of award-winning quality and a dedicated, knowledgeable staff. The following features represent the highlights of the establishment:

UL

LI Award-Winning Heritage: Butterworths was famously voted "Best Bagels in Bergen" by Daily Voice readers, a testament to their standing in a county that takes its bagels very seriously.

LI Professional and Fast Service: Known as a "well-oiled machine," the bakery is praised for its ability to move through long weekend lines quickly without compromising order accuracy.

LI Signature Spreads: The bakery offers a variety of fresh, house-made cream cheeses, with the strawberry spread being a specifically noted favorite among long-time patrons.

LI Knowledgeable Staff: Attendees are recognized for being highly professional and knowledgeable about the menu, helping customers navigate the extensive options with ease.

LI Clean and Inviting Atmosphere: The shop maintains a high standard of cleanliness, providing a pleasant environment for those who choose to enjoy their meal on-site.

LI Small-Batch Consistency: Despite their popularity, the bakery maintains the integrity of a small-batch operation, ensuring that every bagel has the authentic texture and taste of a true New Jersey original.

Contact Information

For those looking to place an order ahead of time or inquire about catering for an upcoming event, Butterworths Bagel Bakery can be reached through the following contact details:

Address: 50 Bi State Plaza, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, USA

Phone: (201) 666-8111

Mobile Phone: +1 201-666-8111

What is worth choosing

When visiting Butterworths Bagel Bakery, the "must-try" item for any newcomer is undoubtedly one of their hand-rolled, made-from-scratch bagels. Specifically, the "everything" bagel paired with their house-made strawberry cream cheese is often cited as a "love at first bite" experience, offering a unique and delightful contrast of savory and sweet flavors. For those who prefer a heartier start to their day, the made-to-order breakfast wraps are an exceptional choice. These wraps are expertly prepared to your specifications, providing a protein-packed meal that is perfect for on-the-go New Jerseyans.

Additionally, for residents hosting a brunch or an office breakfast, the "Baker's Dozen Value Pack" is an unbeatable choice. It includes 13 bagels of your choice along with two tubs of their fresh cream cheese, making it the most efficient way to bring a taste of Old Tappan's best to your group. If you happen to visit during a time when the specialty cheese-covered bagels are available, such as the jalapeño cheddar, they are highly recommended as they tend to sell out quickly. Ultimately, no matter what you choose from the menu—from a simple buttered bagel to a complex breakfast burrito—the quality and freshness at Butterworths Bagel Bakery make it a destination worth visiting time and time again in the Garden State.

Would you like me to help you draft a specific catering order for your next local event or perhaps a social media announcement highlighting your favorite specialty bagel flavor from Butterworths?

Butterworths Bagel Bakery

50 Bi State Plaza, Old Tappan, NJ 07675, USA