Gotta Getta Bagel Introduce
Introduction / Overview
In the bustling neighborhood of Forest Hills, Queens, the search for the perfect morning staple often leads residents and visitors to the local storefronts along the vibrant 71st Avenue corridor. Gotta Getta Bagel is one such establishment that has become a familiar name in the community. Serving a variety of traditional New York-style bagels, cream cheeses, and breakfast sandwiches, this shop caters to a high volume of foot traffic from local professionals, residents, and those visiting the nearby medical offices. As a traditional New York bagel shop, it aims to provide the essential components of a city breakfast: speed, variety, and the classic chew of a kettle-boiled bagel.
The shop operates within a competitive landscape where expectations for quality and accuracy are exceptionally high. In New York, a bagel shop isn't just a place to eat; it is a vital part of the daily routine. Gotta Getta Bagel offers a wide selection of flavors ranging from the classic plain and sesame to the flavor-packed everything bagel. Beyond the bread, they provide various "schmears" and prepared-to-order sandwiches. While the shop serves a large number of patrons daily, it is known for its straightforward, no-frills approach to the New York deli experience. For those navigating the Forest Hills area, it represents a convenient option for a quick bite or a large order for a local office or staff gathering.
Location and Accessibility
Gotta Getta Bagel is strategically located at 107-09 71st Ave, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA. This location is one of the most accessible points in Queens, situated just off the main commercial hub of Continental Avenue. For those utilizing public transportation, the shop is a short walk from the Forest Hills-71st Av subway station, which serves the E, F, M, and R lines, as well as the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) station. This makes it a prime stop for commuters heading into Manhattan or Long Island City.
For visitors arriving by car, the shop is located in a high-density area where street parking can be a challenge, as is common in major New York shopping districts. However, its proximity to various medical facilities and local businesses makes it a frequent stop for people already in the area for appointments. The storefront is easily visible from the street, and the interior is designed for high-volume transactions, allowing customers to move through the line as they head to work or nearby transit hubs. The shop’s position on 71st Avenue ensures it remains a central fixture for the Forest Hills community.
Services Offered
- Freshly baked bagels available in multiple traditional varieties including Plain, Sesame, Everything, and more.
- A wide assortment of cream cheese flavors, featuring house favorites like Scallion and traditional Plain cream cheese.
- Made-to-order breakfast sandwiches, including classic egg and cheese combinations and meat-topped options.
- Bulk order fulfillment for offices, medical staff rewards, and local events (it is recommended to verify orders upon pickup).
- Hot tea and coffee services to accompany breakfast and lunch orders.
- Advance phone orders for pickup, catering to the needs of busy professionals and commuters.
- Toasting services provided upon request for all bagel and sandwich varieties.
Features / Highlights
- Prime Forest Hills Location: Situated in the heart of the 71st Avenue commercial district, offering maximum convenience for subway and LIRR commuters.
- Extensive Schmear Selection: Offers a variety of cream cheese options to allow for high customization of every bagel.
- Traditional Prep Methods: Focuses on the classic New York style of bagel making, providing the familiar taste residents expect.
- Convenience for Local Medical Visitors: Located within walking distance of numerous doctor’s offices, making it a common choice for pre- or post-appointment meals.
- High Volume Capacity: Capable of handling large quantities of bagels for group pickups and staff rewards.
- Direct Customer Feedback: The management is aware of customer feedback regarding order accuracy and service etiquette, which is essential for ongoing improvement.
Contact Information
Address: 107-09 71st Ave, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Phone: (718) 793-1640
Mobile Phone: +1 718-793-1640
What is Worth Choosing
When visiting Gotta Getta Bagel, the most popular choice remains the traditional New York bagel paired with a flavored cream cheese. Specifically, the Everything Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese is a frequently sought-after combination for those who enjoy a savory and aromatic start to their morning. The scallion cream cheese is a staple of the menu, providing a fresh contrast to the toasted seeds and spices of the everything bagel. For those who prefer a simpler profile, the Sesame Bagel is a reliable option that highlights the shop's baking style.
If you are looking for a hot meal, the egg and cheese sandwiches are a standard deli choice that provides a quick, warm breakfast. It is worth noting that for those ordering in large quantities for an office or as a gift, it is highly advisable to perform a quick check of the items before leaving the shop to ensure that all flavor and toasting specifications have been met. For individuals in the neighborhood for medical appointments or those commuting through Forest Hills, a plain toasted bagel with plain cream cheese offers a consistent and quick option. While the area boasts many competitors, Gotta Getta Bagel remains a central choice for those prioritizing a location that is steps away from the major transit and business hubs of Queens.
Gotta Getta Bagel Photos










Gotta Getta Bagel Location
Gotta Getta Bagel
107-09 71st Ave, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
-
Gotta Getta Bagel
107-09 71st Ave
Paris Baguette
107-08 71st Ave
TOUS les JOURS cafe
107-35 71st Ave
Fay Da Bakery
107-50 Queens Blvd
Martha's Country Bakery
70-28 Austin St
Cookies N’ Cream
70-17 Austin St
Pasticceria Amore
107-06 71st Rd
La Boulangerie de François
109-01 72nd Rd
Heena Bagel
108-27 Ascan Ave
Forest Hills Bagels
104-41 Queens Blvd
Bonelle Pastry Shop
108-30 Ascan Ave
Leidylicious Cakes
110-66 Queens Blvd
Bagels for You
113-29 Queens Blvd
Gotta Getta Bagel Reviews
-
I ordered eight bagels for pickup to reward my staff, with a mix of flavors and cream cheese options: (4) Plain Bagels with Plain Cream Cheese (1)Sesame Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese (1) Everything Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese (1) Everything Bagel toasted with Scallion Cream Cheese (1) Plain Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese A total of (8) bagels What I received: (7) bagels, and the items were not as ordered. (6) Plain Bagels with Plain Cream Cheese (1) Sesame Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese Missing items and incorrect toasting/cream cheese requests from the original order. Since this was a pick up order and I work in LIC, I could not go back to the shop. When I called to report the issue, I was told I that I should have checked my order before leaving and, essentially, I should have unwrapped every bagel to inspect each bagel at pickup. That expectation is unreasonable for a prepaid, packaged order of a large qty. The staff member then said, “Come on, be nice, everyone makes mistakes,” which came across as dismissive, unprofessional, and insensitive. This breakfast was a reward for my staff and the fact that the Got To Get A Bagel Inc staff did not care enough to even try to complete the order correctly is disheartening. This level of service does not reflect the quality I expect from a reputable bagel shop. I do not recommend this store based on this experience and hope management takes immediate action to improve order accuracy and how staff handle customer concerns in the future.
Oct 16, 2025 · Pamela Wittmeier -
I was in the area for a doctor’s appointment. Ordered 2 egg and cheese sandwiches and a tea. The people making the sandwiches were nice but the lady at the register was rude like many other reviewers have said. I told her my order in perfect English when I was trying to pay but she asked one of the workers what I ordered because “she couldn’t understand my English.” The food was mediocre. I live by utopia bagels, which is the gold standard but I went here because my doctor is close to this store. What a waste of $20 for mediocre food and a side of attitude and disrespect. My experience is in line with many other reviewers here. Don’t waste your time or money here.
Jan 28, 2026 · Karamjit Singh -
Three stars because the hash browns were unbearable , freezer burn. Although the staff is very friendly and the owner seems very sweet. I got the sesame , Swiss, 2 eggs and pastrami and it was alright. Good price and fair service all together
Mar 02, 2025 · Admir Lalic -
This review is not about my recent experience, but about my overall experience after visiting for years. This place will take advantage of you, charge you whatever price they believe you can pay, and than shame you in front of a long line when you call them on it. I could believe it was an honest mistake the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th time, but at this point I am making a fool out of myself for returning to this location again. This bagel store has pretty okay bagels, which is about its only high point.
Jan 14, 2026 · Jared Kalt -
Lots of good choices besides bagel - salads, paninis, SS wicked, bakery products which is nice. With plenty of fresh produce, prices are expected to be higher. Lots of cream cheese flavors. Bill doesn’t have product name listed which made harder to figure out the charges. Customer service was good. Good was tasty . Just wish the homeless guy doesn’t make the store area stink pee in order for patrons to sit out and enjoy.
Aug 08, 2022 · Kalpa Taru
More Find Bakers
Paris Baguette
4.0 (588 reviews)
107-08 71st Ave, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
TOUS les JOURS cafe
3.0 (60 reviews)
107-35 71st Ave, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Fay Da Bakery
4.0 (523 reviews)
107-50 Queens Blvd, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Martha's Country Bakery
4.0 (5794 reviews)
70-28 Austin St, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Cookies N’ Cream
3.0 (10 reviews)
70-17 Austin St, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Pasticceria Amore
4.0 (34 reviews)
107-06 71st Rd, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
La Boulangerie de François
4.0 (1297 reviews)
109-01 72nd Rd, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Heena Bagel
4.0 (161 reviews)
108-27 Ascan Ave, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Forest Hills Bagels
4.0 (1268 reviews)
104-41 Queens Blvd, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Bonelle Pastry Shop
4.0 (123 reviews)
108-30 Ascan Ave, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Leidylicious Cakes
4.0 (126 reviews)
110-66 Queens Blvd, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Bagels for You
3.0 (330 reviews)
113-29 Queens Blvd, Forest Hills, NY 11375, USA
Categories
Popular
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery4.0 (254 reviews)
Tal Bagels3.0 (1298 reviews)
Butterly Bakeshop4.0 (102 reviews)
Kristi's Bagel Cafe & Bakery4.0 (25 reviews)
Cinnabon0.0 (0 reviews)
Ooga Cookies0.0 (0 reviews)Trending Blog Posts
Top Bakeries in Nashville for Fresh Biscuits and Bread
Top Bakeries in Houston for Fresh Bread and Affordable Pastries
Best Bakeries in Miami for Cuban Bread and Sweet Pastries
Best Bakeries in Portland for Organic and Handmade Bread
Best Bakeries in San Diego for Family-Owned Local Favorites
Best Bakeries in Denver for Small Batch Bread and Coffee
