Capri Bakery Introduce
When it comes to finding an authentic neighborhood gem in the heart of East Harlem, few places capture the spirit of the community quite like Capri Bakery. Situated on the vibrant 116th Street corridor, this establishment has become a staple for New Yorkers seeking traditional flavors, specialized custom cakes, and that unmistakable "home-style" quality that commercial chains simply cannot replicate. For locals, a trip to Capri Bakery is more than just a quick stop for a snack; it is an invitation to experience a piece of New York’s rich culinary tapestry, where the scents of sugar, vanilla, and fresh dough meet the bustling energy of Upper Manhattan.
In a city that never sleeps and is constantly changing, Capri Bakery maintains a reputation for consistency and heart. Whether you are a lifelong resident of El Barrio or a visitor exploring the cultural landmarks of the area, this bakery serves as a sweet sanctuary. Known particularly for its expertise in custom creations and traditional Caribbean-influenced baked goods, Capri Bakery prides itself on creating items that are both visually appealing and satisfying to the palate. The bakery focuses on the fundamentals of good baking: moisture, texture, and flavor balance, ensuring that every bite reminds you why local artisanal shops remain the backbone of New York City’s food scene.
Location and Accessibility
Capri Bakery is strategically located at 186 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029, USA. This prime location puts it right in the center of East Harlem, making it incredibly accessible for those living in or traveling through Upper Manhattan. The bakery is well-served by the New York City subway system, specifically the 6 train, which stops just a short walk away at the 116th St station. This makes it a convenient detour for commuters heading home or for those planning a specific trip to pick up a celebratory cake.
The storefront is nestled within a lively stretch of shops and restaurants, contributing to the walkability of the neighborhood. For those traveling by bus, several local routes pass through the intersection, providing easy access from other parts of the city. While street parking in Manhattan can always be a challenge, the quick-service nature of the bakery allows for efficient pickups. The shop’s presence on 116th Street makes it a landmark for locals who rely on the bakery for their daily bread, morning coffee pairings, or the centerpiece of their weekend family gatherings.
Services Offered
- Custom Cake Design: Specializing in personalized cakes for birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, and baby showers.
- Themed Cupcakes: Individually decorated cupcakes featuring various frosting styles and edible imagery for parties.
- Specialty Fillings: A wide selection of fresh fruit and cream fillings to enhance the internal flavor profile of any cake order.
- Walk-in Pastry Sales: A daily selection of freshly baked cookies, turnovers, and traditional treats available for immediate purchase.
- Edible Image Printing: Technology to transfer photos or logos onto cakes and cupcakes for a personalized touch.
- Consultation for Large Events: Assistance in determining the right size and style of cake for large gatherings and community celebrations.
- Freshness Guarantee: All items are baked with an emphasis on moisture and quality, avoiding the dry texture often found in mass-produced goods.
Features / Highlights
- Moist Cake Texture: Frequently praised for maintaining a perfect moisture level, ensuring the cake tastes just as good the next day.
- Excellent Filling-to-Cake Ratio: Expertly balanced layers that provide enough flavor without overwhelming the sponge.
- Vibrant Visual Presentations: Skilled use of colors and decorations to create eye-catching designs for any festive occasion.
- Community Atmosphere: A classic "New York" bakery feel where staff interact with regular neighborhood customers.
- Traditional Roots: Specializing in the types of flavors and textures that resonate with the local East Harlem demographic.
- Versatile Decoration Styles: Ability to create everything from classic white-frosted elegant cakes to bright, colorful children’s themes.
- Proximity to Transit: Easy access for those using the MTA, making it a "go-to" spot for last-minute celebrations.
Contact Information
Address: 186 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029, USA
Phone: (212) 410-1876
Mobile Phone: +1 212-410-1876
What is worth choosing
If you are planning an event or simply looking to treat yourself, knowing what to order at Capri Bakery can make all the difference. The absolute standout choice at this establishment is their custom-layered cake. Regular customers consistently rave about the "fresh and moist" quality of the cake layers, which sets them apart from the drier varieties found in many grocery stores. The ratio of cake to filling is a particular point of pride; you can expect a generous amount of fresh, flavorful filling that complements the sponge perfectly. For those who enjoy a classic experience, opting for the white frosting is highly recommended, as it allows the natural quality of the ingredients and the freshness of the bake to shine through without the distinct profile of heavy food colorings.
For children’s parties or corporate events, their cupcakes with images are a popular choice. However, when ordering custom work involving edible images, it is always worth having a detailed conversation with the staff. While the presentation is often described as excellent, savvy customers suggest double-checking the application of edible papers to ensure a seamless experience for the little ones. The bakery’s ability to handle custom themes makes it a versatile partner for any New Yorker looking to put a personal stamp on their celebration. Whether it is a simple treat enjoyed straight out of the fridge the next day—which many claim is the best way to eat it—or a grand multi-tiered creation for a first birthday, Capri Bakery offers a reliable, flavorful, and quintessentially East Harlem experience that keeps the community coming back for more.
In conclusion, Capri Bakery represents the heart of local New York commerce. It is a place where the art of baking is practiced with a focus on tradition and taste. By prioritizing moisture, fresh fillings, and neighborhood accessibility, they have maintained their position as a preferred destination for sweets in the 10029 zip code. Whether you need a dozen cupcakes for a school event or a custom cake that will be the talk of your next family reunion, this 116th Street staple stands ready to serve with the expertise that only a local New York institution can provide.
Capri Bakery Photos










Capri Bakery Location
Capri Bakery
186 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029, USA
-
Capri Bakery
186 E 116th St
Don Paco Lopez Panadería
2129 3rd Ave # A
Bermudez Bakery
1875 Lexington Ave
Danny Macaroons
156 E 117th St
Capy Tres Leches Cake
242 E 116th St
Mi Querido Mexico Lindo
249 E 116th St
Bleu Neige Vegan Patisserie ~ONLINE PRE-ORDERS ONLY~
2191 3rd Ave
GO DONUTS
2309 2nd Ave
Milenio Bakery
2030 3rd Ave
CBK Cookies
1580 Park Ave
Pure Confections
1580 Park Ave Kitchen 3
Lady Lexis Sweets
1580 Park Ave
Treats By Trice
2161 2nd Ave
Capri Bakery Reviews
-
Cake was better than expected! Presentation was excellent and fresh and moist. I love that the filling was so good and fresh as well! Great ratio cake filling and frosting! Really great! Next time I would rather do white frosting no food coloring even though the colors were awesome! I prefer no food coloring taste! Love the cake the day after, cold right out of the fridge 😋 yummy! Will order again!
Nov 04, 2025 · Bianca Bella -
So I ordered a custom cake & cupcakes with images on them I asked for it to be 100% completely edible with edible images and I was told it would be since it was for a 1 year old and children party I wanted edible images so no one would choke and they said yes it would be done like I asked. I got the cakes n cupcakes got home everything looked great until it was time to cut the cakes n eat cupcakes. Idk who was just feeling lazy but the cupcake image was cut looking like an amateur baker did it Very uneven and guess what they left the image on the paper they were supposed to peal off before adding to cake. So kids almost choked on the paper. Again the cake its self was good but the work and effort put into it was a disaster and disappointed.
Mar 08, 2026 · Amanda Roman -
I can’t thank you enough. We had an impromptu baby shower and the donuts was a complete hit. So fresh and delicious. I think there might have been a mix up with order but I wasn’t present to receive it, but I everything worked out. Again everybody loved it and I’ll definitely be ordering again.
Feb 10, 2026 · Vrnski Abrahams -
Best place to get a cake. Show them a picture and they will duplicate it. Quality of the finest bakery u can think of for a fraction of the cost
Feb 15, 2026 · Teara Wilson -
The cake was just as pictured and couldn't be more pleased , so delicious. It was for my son 1st birthday and he enjoyed so much . I would recommend Capri bakery for future events
Oct 05, 2025 · Shawn Clarke
More Find Bakers
Don Paco Lopez Panadería
4.0 (156 reviews)
2129 3rd Ave # A, New York, NY 10035, USA
Bermudez Bakery
4.0 (36 reviews)
1875 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10035, USA
Danny Macaroons
4.0 (9 reviews)
156 E 117th St, New York, NY 10035, USA
Capy Tres Leches Cake
4.0 (307 reviews)
242 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029, USA
Mi Querido Mexico Lindo
4.0 (107 reviews)
249 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029, USA
Bleu Neige Vegan Patisserie ~ONLINE PRE-ORDERS ONLY~
4.0 (44 reviews)
2191 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10035, USA
GO DONUTS
3.0 (42 reviews)
2309 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10035, USA
Milenio Bakery
4.0 (29 reviews)
2030 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA
CBK Cookies
3.0 (4 reviews)
1580 Park Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA
Pure Confections
5.0 (45 reviews)
1580 Park Ave Kitchen 3, New York, NY 10029, USA
Lady Lexis Sweets
4.0 (22 reviews)
1580 Park Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA
Treats By Trice
4.0 (147 reviews)
2161 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA
Categories
Popular
Bagel Market4.0 (287 reviews)
Unibread―Fresh Meadows3.0 (112 reviews)
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery4.0 (339 reviews)
Auntie Anne's3.0 (14 reviews)
NaiSnow Tea and Bakery (Columbia University)4.0 (197 reviews)
Iosif Kosher Bakery II, Inc.3.0 (47 reviews)Trending Blog Posts
Top Bakeries in Nashville for Fresh Biscuits and Bread
Top Bakeries in Houston for Fresh Bread and Affordable Pastries
Best Bakeries in Portland for Fresh Sourdough and Natural Fermentation
Best Bakeries in Denver for Fresh Bread and Local Ingredients
Best Bagels in New York from Local Bakeries
Best Bakeries in Dallas for Handmade Bread and Pastries
